Why E-Waste Often Gets a Second Life

2020/10/03

Preface

Q: Why does e-waste so often get a second life?
A: Hackintosh.

My very first personal computer was a 2015 MacBook Pro. As the last MBP with the iconic glowing Apple logo, it still holds its value well, and plenty of power users are still using it today. The usability of macOS, its support for high-DPI displays, a software environment that’s a bit less shady, and the incredibly strong ecosystem have always had a firm grip on me. I’d been eyeing last year’s 16-inch model for a long time, so I kept feeling like my current machine was starting to run out of steam. But with the high price, my not-so-high budget, plus the temptation to wait for ARM at the end of the year and Tiger Lake next year… well, the “wait-and-see” crowd never really loses.

Sure enough, the one who understands me best is always Zhang Damei. Recently there were a few M73 Hackintosh posts on SMZDM, and they were just too good. The Lenovo M73, a 1L mini PC from years ago, can do so much for just a bit over 200 RMB. That instantly made me dig those videos back up and review them properly. After watching, my scavenger-builder spirit reignited, and I decided to build one myself. I really hadn’t experienced what macOS felt like on a standard-voltage CPU before. I’d previously messed around with Hackintosh on a NUC8i5 and a T470, but the experience was pretty average. I’d followed Xiao Bing’s blog, lurked around PCEVA, and had even seen Sibotu’s M73 video before, but I didn’t pay much attention to it at the time.

The reason I ignored it back then was that I used to firmly believe in “buy new, not old,” always trying to ride the wave of the times. Then I discovered Xianyu and became a junk hardware guy… but that’s another story. Later, though, I realized my work computer had a 4th-gen i5-4590, and surprisingly, it was really good. I don’t know whether Intel has just always been this slippery, or whether the workloads I use daily simply don’t need that much horsepower. After doing a lot of research and comparisons, I found that aside from Intel’s years of incremental “toothpaste squeezing,” the 4th-gen Haswell architecture actually isn’t that far behind modern Coffee Lake in single-core performance. The gap is more obvious in multi-threading and power consumption.

So I wrote this article as the first post in my tinkering section, just to document the process. Since I’ve been playing with Hackintosh for quite a while, this article leans a bit more toward unboxing and tutorial content. Hopefully it can also give some ideas to others who want to tinker with the same thing. All the software tools used in this article are provided at the end, and you can jump there directly from the table of contents on the right. The EFI I used is based on Sibotu’s third version. Honestly, his work was already very complete. I only changed three things: 1. Set the VRAM size to 2048MB to reduce graphical glitches. 2. Added speaker support for the M73. 3. Disabled verbose boot mode.

Unboxing the M73

Back in August, I was still seeing these for around 200 RMB. Now they’ve gone up to 280 and often don’t even include a power adapter. I finally found a seller whose machine looked clean, and for 280 shipped, it even came with a 65W adapter. Since I’m using a 4690T, I felt like 65W might be cutting it a bit close, but hey, free power adapter, might as well use it first. When it arrived, I was honestly shocked. The machine looked very new, and the packaging gave me a real sense of security.

Neatly packed, the kind of packaging that instantly makes you feel like this was a good deal

Neatly packed, the kind of packaging that instantly makes you feel like this was a good deal


The power adapter was a bit smaller than I expected, though. During the pandemic my main computer was left at school, so I bought a ThinkPad T490 at home for study convenience, and that one also came with a 65W USB-C charger. That charger was huge. I seriously suspect Lenovo intentionally made it bigger just to help sell those lipstick-sized chargers… same wattage, bigger body. Amazing. Anyway, this one is rated at 65W too, and I’ll test later whether there’s enough headroom.

65W square-tip power adapter

65W square-tip power adapter


The whole machine looks very new, though you can still spot some signs of use on the smoother surfaces

The whole machine looks very new, though you can still spot some signs of use on the smoother surfaces


This thing originally came with Windows 8 Pro. Fancy, fancy.

This thing originally came with Windows 8 Pro. Fancy, fancy.


On the front, there are separate 3.5mm headphone and mic jacks, plus two USB 3.1 ports. The yellow one supports 10W charging while powered off. But with only a 65W power adapter, I’d really suggest not using it to charge your phone. That’s the last straw that breaks the camel’s back for this little machine, and it can trip power in no time. The rows of diagonal slits are fin-style ventilation openings. They’re for balancing airflow, not actual cooling vents. There’s also the power button on the front, and this button has a weirdly mysterious feel to it—kind of loose and wobbly, but somehow still satisfying to press…..

The front I/O is also pretty rich

The front I/O is also pretty rich


On the back, from left to right, there’s Lenovo’s signature square power connector, a DisplayPort for the monitor, two USB 2.0 ports for peripherals, an ancient VGA port—but Apple doesn’t support VGA, so if you install Hackintosh, that one becomes useless—a gigabit RJ45 Ethernet port, another USB 2.0, and the little hole above the far-right USB is for the Wi-Fi antenna. Even though my network access is via Wi-Fi, I plan to use soft antennas mounted inside the top cover instead of sticking an external antenna out the back. That just looks kind of ugly to me. The grille in the upper-left corner is the cooling vent, and inside there’s a copper heat pipe and fan setup.

IMG_2276

The rear ports are usable enough


Officially, it’s only 1L in volume. A 250ml Coke bottle, basically—that’s about the scale. It’s roughly half the size of a laptop, though still noticeably bigger than Intel’s NUC. But… well, price matters here. In terms of performance, this thing uses a standard-voltage CPU, so the raw compute power should be much stronger, though the integrated graphics are definitely weaker.

IMG_1315

Front size comparison of the chassis


You can clearly see it’s about half the size of a soda can. Since it’s a desktop, portability isn’t really part of the discussion, but u1s1, it really does save a lot of space at home.

IMG_4287

Side thickness comparison of the chassis


The monitor is one of those “King of Budget” models from last year, using a BOE 300-nit IPS 4K panel. JD often runs promotions and it goes for under 1000 RMB. Even though customer service said it doesn’t support macOS very well, practice is the only real test. This thing is a Hackintosh weapon—cheaper than building your own display setup in many cases. I honestly have no idea how the seller makes money on it.

IMG_0485

Very convenient to mount behind the monitor


Parts

Below is all the hardware I used. I went with relatively good parts, and the CPU and RAM are basically maxed out, so the price is a bit higher. Luckily, I already had some of it lying around in the junk pile. If you’re just getting into this, I’d suggest going with an i3 and 8GB of RAM—that should be enough, and you can probably get it all done for around 700–800 RMB.

Name Xianyu Market Price Actual Cost
Barebone - M73 280 280
CPU - 4690T 400 0 (already owned)
RAM - Kingston DDR3L 8G*2 150*2 0 (already owned)
Wi-Fi Card - BCM94352HMB 100 100
SSD - Kingston SATA 240G 150 0 (already owned)
Total 1,230 780

Since the seller only provided the main unit, it was basically a barebone system—just a case and motherboard, with everything else needing to be added by yourself. That’s actually friendlier in a way, because the parts you choose are more controllable. Let me go over the hardware I used this time:

This is basically the strongest T-series CPU on the LGA1150 socket. Its integrated graphics are HD4600, which can handle 4K at 60Hz. What I really cared about was the iGPU, because I have a 4K display, and on macOS, if you’re not running 4K with HiDPI, what kind of experience is that? But the tradeoff is obvious too: the price is very high. On Xianyu, this CPU usually costs about twice as much as the host machine itself… pretty scary. But I found a good seller, haggled shamelessly, played cute, chatted warmly, and finally got it for 400. A real lucky find~. The condition was also excellent. On Xianyu, CPUs in this kind of shape are basically impossible to find. Most are scratched all over or covered in layers of labels. Finding one this fresh, clearly first-hand and personally used, is honestly rare.

IMG_6377

4th-gen i5 4690T


If I’m already using such a nice CPU, how could I not also take care of the RAM? These sticks had been sitting idle for a long time. I kept thinking about selling them, but couldn’t bear to do it, so they just stayed around. For this article, I specifically checked the current price, and I was shocked—used DDR3 8GB sticks are somehow still going for 150 RMB or more. That’s pure metaphysics. Totally unexpected, especially since brand-new DDR4 8GB can also be had for around 150 now. Clearly there are just too many junk hardware tinkerers out there, all messing with old gear and keeping the prices alive.

IMG_7701

Kingston 8G*2 dual-channel 16G


This is the Wi-Fi card. At 100 RMB, it was basically free. The condition was so good I suspect it was also first-hand, unlike the flashy label-covered monsters all over Xianyu. There are lots of tutorials online claiming to teach you how to build a “perfect Hackintosh,” and what they usually mean by “perfect” is that AirDrop works. That makes sense, because AirDrop is one of the signature features of the Apple ecosystem—file transfer between devices, shared clipboard across devices, iPad Sidecar, and a whole bunch of really practical features all build on top of that foundation. But the requirements are extremely strict. Ordinary Wi-Fi cards usually can’t achieve this, because Apple only uses Broadcom Wi-Fi cards, and Broadcom cards are OEM-only—they’re not sold directly to regular consumers… So the best solution is to use a pulled card, like one salvaged from a broken Apple computer and resold. They’re expensive, but it’s still the best option. And now Apple’s hardware control is getting stricter and stricter—for example, using the T2 chip to secure hardware, and soldering the Wi-Fi card directly onto the motherboard. Every pulled card used is one fewer left in the world. So what are you waiting for?

IMG_2817

The soul of a Hackintosh - BCM94352HMB


IMG_0887

A 240G Kingston SSD gifted by a friend


This thermal paste is a few years old now, with 8.5W thermal conductivity—one of the strongest consumer-grade thermal pastes out there, and priced accordingly. When I bought it, 8g cost nearly 100 RMB. I’ve been using it on and off ever since, and honestly, 8g lasting four or five years is pretty worth it. I bought this back in my freshman year of college, also for tinkering reasons. On a whim, I wanted to replace the thermal paste on my then-new laptop….. It’s the same logic as buying an expensive case or screen protector for a brand-new phone. I gritted my teeth and bought this pricey paste. Of course, once the computer gets old, you stop caring and just let it run hot however it wants…. It’s still sold on JD now for 60 RMB per 8g, so the price is still holding strong.

IMG_4433

ARCTIC thermal paste


Assembly

Now that the intro is done, let’s start disassembling and assembling.

IMG_5060

There’s one screw on the back—unscrew it


IMG_5353

Remove the fan


IMG_6676

Remove the heat pipe


After opening it up, I was honestly a bit surprised. The motherboard was unbelievably clean—no dust at all, and the PCB was shiny as hell. Huge win, huge win. Next, just install the hardware one by one.

IMG_9252

Full view of the motherboard


First, install the CPU.

IMG_2846

Use the little tab above to open the cover


This is still the same old issue everyone talks about: line up the notches properly, and don’t mess up the pins. Once you bend even one pin, it’s usually very hard to save, so make sure everything is aligned before pressing the retention plate down. Don’t try to brute-force a miracle.

IMG_5534

Align the notches, place the CPU down, then use the little tab to secure it


For the RAM, start with the inner slot first. Align the notch at the bottom, insert it, then press down until you hear a “click.” That’s one stick installed. Then do the same for the upper slot and press down until you hear another “click.”

IMG_6765

Press the RAM sticks into place


This motherboard is kind of interesting—it uses clips for mounting. At the top of the Wi-Fi card there’s a spot for the antenna connection. Since connecting it now would make things look messy, I’ll attach it to the top cover later.

IMG_7601

Then install the Wi-Fi card


Now install the heatsink and fan. Before that, apply the thermal paste. I’m using the globally best, absolutely indisputable X-pattern method. For a standard-voltage CPU like this, the application pattern actually matters quite a bit. On low-voltage chips it’s more like psychological comfort. The X-pattern is indeed widely considered, both in China and abroad, to be one of the better ways to spread the paste evenly. I’ve always done it this way.

IMG_8789

Apply thermal paste to the CPU


Dell and HP have similar mini PCs, but they often don’t use heat pipes and rely only on the fan pressing down directly. By comparison, Lenovo added a copper heat pipe here, which should provide better cooling and allow better performance.

IMG_3719

Then install the heat pipe and fan


IMG_6527

A drive bracket included with the machine—mount the SSD onto it


I didn’t plug in this cable yet, because I still need to route the Wi-Fi antenna underneath, and plugging it in now would block the way.

IMG_2208

Just screw it in according to the holes


IMG_0942

Two antenna cables, one end connects to the Wi-Fi card (and don’t forget to plug in the SATA connector afterward)


IMG_1893

The other ends of the two antenna cables connect to the top cover of the machine


IMG_8592

Ta-da~ ta-da~ ta-da~ one last look before closing the lid


Creating the Boot Image

The core of a Hackintosh is the EFI, not the boot image or the system image. So I didn’t follow the common approach of pre-configuring all kinds of EFI parameters in advance like many current guides do. Most people try to do everything in one shot, which raises the barrier too high and scares off beginners. My approach is to first use Sibotu’s default EFI, then after entering the system, use the eternal god of Hackintosh tools—Hackintool—to adjust the parameters. My philosophy is that the important stuff should be tuned carefully at the end. So I simplified the installation into just two steps.

  1. For the boot image, I used one that had already been downloaded offline, and wrote it to my USB drive using the “imageUSB” software, then booted into the installer from the USB drive.

    1. Download and open the resource pack, then open the first folder inside it - Create Boot USB. There are two files inside: imageUSB.exe, which is the tool used to write the USB drive, and bootloader.img, which is the boot image modified for the M73 based on Apple’s offline download.

    image-20200929115012282

    The resource pack will be provided at the end of the article; this is the first folder in it


    1. Open imageUSB.exe, then in the big box in step 1, select your USB drive. In step 3, specify the bootloader.img mentioned above. Leave everything else unchanged, then click write.

    image-20200929115431485

    Click write to start flashing the image


    1. Wait for the progress bar to finish. Then check the USB drive you just wrote to—you’ll see its volume name has changed to BOOT. Open the USB drive and you’ll find only one EFI folder inside (there’s actually also a hidden folder). At this point, the USB drive is already capable of booting our EFI. But as mentioned above, the core of Hackintosh is the EFI, and future upgrades or iterations mainly involve replacing EFI files. So to make sure the EFI is the latest version, we’ll replace it once more. The replacement file is in the second folder of the resource pack provided in this article - 2.EFI (please copy the EFI folder inside). Just like the folder name says, copy the EFI folder inside and replace the one under the BOOT volume.

    image-20200929143305

    Replace the EFI


At this point, the bootable USB drive is ready, and next we’ll use it to boot the M73 into macOS installation. A lot of people might be wondering right now: That’s it? That’s it? That’s it? Other people’s guides are full of long, complicated steps. In reality, I didn’t skip a single step—I just used a simpler way to achieve the same result. Of course, there are tradeoffs. For example, in Sibotu’s guide, you need to install Python and run the scripts he provides. His scripts download the macOS recovery image from Apple’s official servers, then you have to go through a more complicated process to choose the version info, and then the script writes the image to the USB drive and adjusts the EFI afterward. That whole process is really discouraging for beginners. Downloading the image offline and writing it with software is much simpler, but the downside is that you can’t dynamically fetch the recovery image version. It really just depends on what you prefer. My suggestion is to first achieve the goal with the simplest method, then spend time later understanding the underlying principles.

  1. The system image itself is downloaded and installed online from Apple’s official servers by the recovery program in the installer interface.

Insert the USB drive you just created, press that weirdly satisfying power button, and let’s begin the system installation. On the POST screen, press F12 once to enter the boot device selection menu, and choose the bootable USB drive we made. After entering, the first screen shown by the USB bootloader will appear. On this screen, choose the option for entering the boot USB functions—we want the third one, which is Apple’s official system recovery mode. Through this recovery mode, we’ll install macOS 10.15.6 online onto the computer. Use the keyboard up/down arrows and Enter to move and confirm. If you don’t make any selection within 3 seconds, it will automatically boot into the first option by default. Since we need the third one, you have to act quickly. If you want to study the screen more carefully, just press any key to interrupt the auto-boot. After selecting it, some related code will run, and you may see lots of log messages you don’t understand. Don’t worry about them—just wait.

First, press the power button

First, press the power button


Once the screen lights up, quickly press F12 on the POST screen

Once the screen lights up, quickly press F12 on the POST screen


After pressing F12, enter the boot menu and select your USB drive (usually the one starting with USB)

After pressing F12, enter the boot menu and select your USB drive (usually the one starting with USB)


IMG_9130

Quickly choose the third option to enter Apple’s official recovery mode


IMG_6354

Wait for the code to finish running


IMG_0376

Successfully entered Apple’s official recovery mode (macOS Utilities)


At this point, we’re already halfway there. Next, we just need to format the system drive to prepare it for installation, then let Apple automatically install the system for us. Very foolproof.

IMG_6015

First choose Disk Utility and format the drive


IMG_8517

Select the internal SSD and erase it


IMG_0318

You can name it whatever you want, but please choose APFS as the format—this is Apple’s latest system-specific format


IMG_9176

Success!!! Then close it and return to the previous screen


IMG_5150

Choose Reinstall macOS


IMG_9232

It prompts that a network connection is required, because this is an online installation and the time depends on your internet speed


IMG_5796

Because I’m using a pulled Wi-Fi card, I can connect to Wi-Fi even before the system is installed. If you didn’t buy one, you can use wired Ethernet


After that, just proceed with the installation. Keep clicking Next and wait for the system to install automatically. It may reboot multiple times during the process. Be careful not to unplug the boot USB drive, because on reboot the bootloader is needed to bring the system back into the installer. After each reboot, just choose the first option, macOS installer. Otherwise, the computer will complain that it can’t find an operating system and keep trying to reboot. Once installation is complete, we’ll copy the boot EFI to the hard drive, so future reboots will work like a normal computer.

IMG_1772

IMG_0372

Then just keep clicking Next like a total foolproof wizard


IMG_5566

After the automatic reboot, it will return to the boot menu—just choose the first option (if you do nothing for 3 seconds, it enters automatically)


IMG_4395

IMG_1578

Once installation is complete, the first option will change to the name you gave the formatted drive—this will be your macOS system from now on


At this point, the system has already been installed onto the hard drive, but we’re still booting through the USB drive. We still need to enter the system and write the USB boot files onto the hard drive.

IMG_2871

First complete the initial setup of the new system—just keep clicking Next


IMG_0702

Don’t enter your Apple ID here yet—choose Set Up Later, because we haven’t generated the SMBIOS values yet


IMG_5723

Keep clicking Next, and after a few minutes you’ll enter the system—proper 4K with HiDPI scaled to 1080p


At this point, macOS is installed on the M73. The steps here are probably the simplest you’ll find in public guides. Honestly, after generations of effort from the community, installing a Hackintosh is now even easier than installing Windows in some ways. Once the boot drive is ready, the rest is mostly handled by Apple’s own tools. But the real key is compatibility—after the system is installed, how do you minimize the rejection between your hardware and macOS? Aside from choosing hardware as close as possible to real Macs, the rest is endless adaptation, spoofing, and trial and error. After all, not every machine is as blessed as the NUC8. So next, we’ll enter the system, get rid of USB booting, spoof a few incompatible hardware components, and generate SMBIOS values so we can sign in to Apple ID.

Post-Boot Adjustments

From here on, all screenshots are from macOS. It’s not hard to see that macOS really is gorgeous.

  • Check completion status

    iShot2020-10-02 14.14.05

    Latest system version


    Spoofed as a 2015 iMac

    Spoofed as a 2015 iMac


    iShot2020-10-02 14.11.27

    Bluetooth 4.1 working normally


    iShot2020-10-02 14.10.51

    HiDPI looks great


    iShot2020-10-02 16.40.56

    AirDrop is very fast


  • Get rid of USB booting and put EFI onto the system drive

    Right now we’re only 80% done. The computer works, but if you reboot it, it’s game over. We now need to put the USB bootloader onto the hard drive. We’ll use a tool to mount the system’s EFI partition, then delete the system EFI and replace it with ours. The steps are as follows:

    iShot2020-10-02 13.54.22

    Extract Hackintool from folder 3 in the resource pack and copy it into Applications


    iShot2020-10-02 13.55.18

    After opening the software, click Disks, then click the red-circled button shown in the image, and enter your password


    iShot2020-10-02 13.55.32

    After that, the red-circled button in this image becomes clickable—click it to open the EFI partition


    Open the EFI partition. Inside there will be a system EFI folder. Delete it and replace it with the EFI from folder 2 of the resource pack, or the EFI currently on your boot USB drive (they’re the same, so just use whichever is more convenient).

    iShot2020-10-02 13.56.00

    Open the EFI partition, delete the existing EFI folder inside, and replace it with the M73-specific boot EFI


    iShot2020-10-02 13.56.42

    Directory structure after replacement


    At this point, the EFI replacement is complete. The machine can now boot independently and work normally, and you can unplug the boot USB drive.

  • Generate SMBIOS values so you can sign in to Apple ID

    Apple is famously strict about product control. Its globally unique serial numbers make counterfeiting much harder. We now need to generate a serial number for our computer so that we can sign in to Apple ID. Although the resource pack already includes one set of SMBIOS values, everyone can use that same set, and if too many people do, Apple ID may get blocked. So we’ll use Hackintool to generate our own:

    iShot2020-10-02 15.00.10

Open Hackintool, choose serial number generation, then click the icon marked as 2 in the image


iShot2020-10-02 15.00.44

Take the generated serial number to Apple’s official site to verify it


iShot2020-10-02 15.04.59

If Apple’s site can’t find it, that means it’s safe to use


iShot2020-10-02 15.01.55

If it can be found like this, then don’t use it—generate another one


iShot2020-10-02 15.06.01

Then open the EFI partition we just mounted, and find the `config` file inside the EFI folder you copied earlier


iShot2020-10-02 15.06.58

Search for `PlatformInfo` to locate this section (I used VSCode to open it)


iShot2020-10-02 15.08.45

iShot2020-10-02 15.09.32

Copy the generated values into the corresponding fields, then reboot


iShot2020-10-02 16.45.31

After rebooting, just sign in normally—it’s so realistic that it even asks whether you want to enable Find My


Summary

After countless forced shutdowns, countless image writes, and endless EFI modifications and replacements, I finally got Hackintosh running on the M73. I have to say, a standard-voltage CPU really feels amazing. I originally thought the fan wouldn’t be able to handle the heat, but in reality, the fan is extremely quiet—you can only hear it if you get close—yet it can sustain a 40W output, which really surprised me.

Overall, it’s pretty close to perfect. I didn’t run into any software issues, and the experience feels very similar to my real Mac. The only issue is that wake-from-sleep sometimes fails, but after enabling TRIM on the SSD, it got much better. Now it’s just a slight delay. There are actually many more software-side and BIOS-side tuning steps that I didn’t explain in detail due to length. If I come across another machine like this that’s just too good to pass up, I’ll definitely share it again.

In the end, even though Hackintosh has all sorts of little issues, that doesn’t stop me from loving it. Sure, it’s a lot of tinkering, but when you fully throw yourself into something, slowly moving forward through repeated mistakes, the sense of achievement when you finally succeed is more than enough to keep me hooked.

Looks like I worried too much—the 65W power adapter is enough after all, though it can sustain 40W output

Looks like I worried too much—the 65W power adapter is enough after all, though it can sustain 40W output


Basic information

Basic information


Intel introduction for the 4690T

Intel introduction for the 4690T


Daily idle temperature

Daily idle temperature


Resources

  1. The resource pack is shared via Tianyi Cloud. Login is required, but no client download is needed, and I personally confirmed there’s no speed limit. Tianyi Cloud resource pack sharing page

    https://cloud.189.cn/t/BRvAZjBJ73e2


  2. VSCode may also be useful—download it from the official website (though you can actually just edit with Notepad)
  3. https://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/?LinkID=620882center>

All articles in this blog, unless otherwise stated, are licensed under @Oreoft . Please indicate the source when reprinting!

Table of Contents